← Storied Sambhu Nath De — Storied No. 095
StoriedNo. 095Medicine · Pathology
LIGATED ILEAL LOOP RABBIT · 1953 / 1959
His experiment, drawn. No public-domain photograph of him could be confirmed.

Sambhu Nath De

1915  —  1985

Koch found the cholera germ in Calcutta. Seventy-five years later, in the same city, a pathologist showed how it kills.

In 1884 Robert Koch grew the comma-shaped bacillus of cholera in Calcutta, and then taught the world that it killed with a poison that ran through the whole body. For three-quarters of a century, researchers injected cholera cultures into the veins, bellies and muscles of animals, and got almost nowhere. Sambhu Nath De, a pathologist at a Calcutta teaching hospital, did something simpler. He tied off a short loop of a rabbit's small intestine with silk thread and put the germ only there. The loop filled with fluid. In 1959 he showed that the broth alone, with every bacterium filtered out, did the same thing. Cholera was a toxin acting on the gut wall.

That idea now underpins modern cholera research and oral vaccines, and it explains why a drink of salts and sugar can save a dying patient. His two-page paper in Nature was cited three times in four years. He died in 1985, in the words of one Indian editor, "unhonoured and unsung in India's scientific circles."

A village boy, a teaching lab

The lifeline

1915
Born 1 February in Garbati, Hooghly district, Bengal, to a family of modest means
1939
Qualifies in medicine at Calcutta Medical College; an uncle had paid his way
1949
Earns a London PhD under Roy Cameron in two years, and comes home
1953
Ligates a rabbit's ileum and makes cholera happen in a single loop of gut
1959
Shows in Nature that a germ-free filtrate is enough: the toxin is the disease
1985
Dies in Calcutta on 15 April, aged 70, little known at home
By the numbers

The measure of it

75
Years from Koch's proposed cholera poison (1884) to De's demonstration of it (1959)
2
Pages: the length of his 1959 letter to Nature, vol. 183, pp. 1533–34
3
Citations that paper received between 1959 and 1963
11,168
PubMed papers on "cholera toxin" counted in November 2009
What he found

The work

1949
A PhD in two years at University College Hospital Medical School, London. His supervisor, the pathologist Roy Cameron, called him "one of the most outstanding of young men I have had through my hands."
1953
The rabbit ileal loop. With D. N. Chatterje he tied off segments of rabbit intestine and introduced live Vibrio cholerae; the loops filled with fluid. He had re-invented, unknowingly, a forgotten 1915 method, and used it to aim at the gut wall rather than the blood.J. Pathol. Bacteriol. 66 · 1953
1956
Not only cholera. Strains of E. coli from patients with enteritis filled the loops too, the first step toward what is now called enterotoxigenic E. coli, a leading cause of diarrhoea worldwide.J. Pathol. Bacteriol. 71 · 1956
1959
The toxin itself. Culture broth with every bacterium filtered out still made the loops fill. Cholera was caused by an exotoxin acting on the intestine, not a poison spreading through the body.Nature 183 · 1959
Later
The consequences. Once his idea was accepted, it gave cholera vaccines a scientific basis for being taken by mouth, and it explained why oral rehydration works. He had no staff or equipment to purify the toxin himself; others did that in the late 1960s.
Unsung, then sung

Recognition

In his lifetime

  • The Nature paper drew 3 citations in four years; one claimed it could not be repeated
  • Worked in an undergraduate teaching department, without the staff or equipment to purify his toxin
  • Retired in 1973 at 58
  • Abroad, Joshua Lederberg nominated him for a Nobel Prize more than once, and he was invited to the 1978 Nobel Symposium on cholera. At home he received little notice

Since

  • Eugene Garfield's 1986 study held him up as a case of "delayed recognition"; two of his papers became Citation Classics
  • Current Science devoted a special issue to him in 1990
  • Calcutta University awarded him an honorary D.Sc. in 1994, nine years after his death
  • The Indian Journal of Medical Research marked the 50th anniversary of his discovery with a special issue in 2011
Where cholera was studied, and solved

Calcutta

De grew up in a Hooghly district village upriver from Calcutta and spent nearly his whole career in the city, in the Bengal delta, long called cholera's homeland. Koch's German commission had cultured the comma bacillus there in 1884. Seventy-five years later, in an under-equipped teaching laboratory in the same city, De showed what the bacillus actually does.

1884
Koch cultures Vibrio cholerae in Calcutta
1959
De, in the same city, demonstrates its toxin
1963
The US National Institutes of Health begins weighing his toxin theory
"Workers in developed countries cannot imagine how difficult it is to carry out and continue research work without willing personnel and without equipment in an undergraduate teaching department in a country like ours." — Sambhu Nath De, writing to the cholera historian W. E. van Heyningen
Share X WhatsApp LinkedIn Reddit

Get it in your inbox

Like this life? Get a new one in your inbox every morning.