For years he painted coal tar on rabbits’ ears until he became the first person to make cancer in a laboratory, and the Nobel went to a man who was wrong.
In 1775 a London surgeon, Percival Pott, noticed that chimney sweeps were dying of cancer of the scrotum and blamed the soot. For the next 140 years, nobody could prove him right. Researchers rubbed tar and soot on animals in laboratory after laboratory, saw sores and small growths, and gave up. Cancer, it seemed, could not be made on purpose. And if you couldn’t make it, you couldn’t study how it began.
In Tokyo, a pathologist who had trained under Rudolf Virchow and was himself sick with tuberculosis tried again. He was more patient than anyone before him. With his young assistant Kōichi Ichikawa, Katsusaburō Yamagiwa painted coal tar on the insides of rabbits’ ears every two or three days, month after month, picking off the dried crust with tweezers each time. In 1915 real, invasive carcinoma appeared, and some tumours spread to the lymph nodes. It was the first time anyone had produced cancer with a chemical. The whole science of carcinogens grew out of that experiment.
From castle town to cancer ward
The lifeline
1863
Born in the castle town of Ueda, Shinano, third son of a samurai retainer of the Ueda domain
1892
Sent to Germany to study under Robert Koch and Rudolf Virchow
1895
Made professor of pathology at the Imperial University of Tokyo
1899
Falls ill with pulmonary tuberculosis and keeps working through treatment
1915
With Ichikawa, produces the world’s first chemically induced cancer
1930
Dies of pneumonia in Tokyo, aged 66, never having won the Nobel
By the numbers
The measure of the experiment
131
Rabbit ears tarred across his four experimental series, 1914–15
2–3 days
The interval between paintings, kept up for months on end
579
Days into the experiment when one rabbit’s tar cancer was found to have spread to a lymph node
7
Nominations for the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine. He never won it.
What he built
The work
1895
Byōri Sōron Kōgi (Lectures on General Pathology), his landmark textbook, which helped found modern pathology in Japan.
1907
Founds Gann, Japan’s first journal of cancer research. It still runs today as Cancer Science.
1908
Co-founds the Japanese Foundation for Cancer Research, today one of Japan’s leading cancer institutes.
1915
The first artificial cancer. Reported on 25 September 1915 with Ichikawa: carcinoma on rabbits’ ears caused by nothing more than coal tar and chronic irritation.
1915–24
Six reports under one title, covering metastasis, the stages by which tumours develop, and tumours induced with tar in other tissues. His model became the standard way to test whether a substance causes cancer.
Passed over, then vindicated
Recognition
In his lifetime
His first reports came out in Japan during the First World War and reached Europe late
Nominated for the Nobel in 1925, 1926 and 1928
The 1926 prize went to Johannes Fibiger for a cancer he said a parasitic worm caused
Honoured at home with the Imperial Academy Prize in 1919, shared with Ichikawa
Today
In 1952, Fibiger’s “tumours” were shown to be lesions linked to vitamin A deficiency, not cancer
Fibiger’s 1926 Nobel is widely cited as one of the prize’s great mistakes
Folke Henschen, who reviewed the 1926 case for the Nobel committee, later wrote in Yamagiwa’s favour
Painting chemicals on skin, as he did with tar, remains the basis of chemical carcinogenesis research
The place that made him
Ueda, Shinano
He was born into the samurai class of a small mountain domain in what is now Nagano Prefecture. He was later adopted by a doctor named Yamagiwa, a man from his home region, which is how he got the surname and his path into medicine. Ueda remembers him now: a bronze bust of the pathologist stands in Ueda Castle Park.
1583
Ueda Castle built by the Sanada clan
2 sieges
Tokugawa armies held off at Ueda in 1585 and 1600
1 bust
Yamagiwa, cast in bronze in Ueda Castle Park
癌出来つ 意気昂然と 二歩三歩“Cancer is identified! Proudly I walk a few steps.”
— Yamagiwa’s haiku on the 1915 result (as translated by Hirota Fujiki, 2014)